Unlocking At-Will Employment: Laws, Exceptions, and Guide

As of 2023, approximately 94% of private-sector employees in the U.S. work under at-will employment agreements. This means that most employees can be terminated at any time, for any legal reason, without the need for prior notice or a specific cause, except in Montana, where certain protections apply after a probationary period. This structure enables employers to dismiss employees at any time and for any reason, provided that dismissal is not unlawful. Likewise, employees have an open right to quit working without any notice or even being penalized. This flexibility benefits employers by making it easier to manage a diverse workforce, but it presents a challenge for employees due to the risk of job insecurity.

This blog will be about understanding the at-will employment termination process where we will look for legal provisions and exceptions in every state and industry. We will also highlight how federal laws against employment discrimination safeguard employees and provide an overview of the pros and cons of at-will employment for both parties. In the case of employers, it is important to know your rights while on the other hand for the employees, it is important to know how you stand in the modern workplace especially if employment is at-will.

What is at-will employment?

Employment at will means the employee has the right to end the employment relationship any time without any advance notice and for any cause at all provided the dismissal does not violate the common law and statute. It is characteristic for countries such as the U.S., and it provides a great deal of freedom both for the employer and the employee.

For employers, one of the main benefits of at-will employment is the ability to quickly adjust staffing levels without needing to go through lengthy legal or contractual processes. The last primary protection type under this section means that employers can dismiss an employee without providing any reason or going through bargaining sessions. In the same regard, employee also have the opportunity to quit their employment at any time, and they do not suffer losses in laws as those charged with breach of contract.

Unlike other types of employment, at-will employment does not need any special clauses regarding conditions of termination or the length of notice in cases of termination. However, employees under this system of work arrangements are usually offered less statutory employment protections than those who enjoy the benefits of at-will employment contracts.

The at-will employment termination process

The at-will employment termination process permits employers to eliminate the employees at their own discretion for any reasons except legal prohibited reasons. In practical terms, this means that an employer can dismiss an employee at will without prior notice and even without “the rigmarole” associated with the dismissal process – which is one of the attractions of this system. Of course, this freedom implies certain obligations and can be dangerous.

This means that despite the advantages that come with at-will employment, there are certain legal constraints. For instance, an employer is prohibited from terminating an employee for discrimination, retaliation, or for violating public policy. If an employer dismisses someone for reasons that contravene these protections he/she could find him/herself staring at a wrongful dismissal lawsuit. The primary concern of discharging at-will employees is that it may be contested on such legal premises as discrimination, retaliation, or breach of implied contracts.

To avoid such risks, employers should make and retain adequate records even when the employee is hired under an at-will clause. Documentation of termination is preferable when it is lawful and has no connection with discrimination against the TORs. Where an employee is dismissed for poor performance or misconduct, evidence of prior related written warnings, appraisals or disciplinary measures will assist in defending the organization against legal proceedings. A paper done by the society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) reveals that improper documentation is one of the significant reasons for wrongful dismissal legal actions in the at-will employment frameworks. Employers must also be cautious about good faith termination lawsuits, which can arise if employees believe they were dismissed unfairly or in bad faith.

Federal laws against employment discrimination

While at-will employment grants employers the ability to terminate employees freely, federal laws against employment discrimination ensure that this power is not abused. There are several federal legislation that serve to protect the employees, which makes dismissal on grounds of discrimination unlawful.

The most well-known law is called Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and it is against discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex or national origin. This means that employers cannot fire employees under any of these grounds even if the employees serve under the at-will employment. Yet another important legal provision is the Americans with Disabilities Act which outlaws discrimination of employees with consideration on issues such as dismissal. Under this law, an employer is required to adopt undue accommodations for a disabled employee provided that the adoption of accommodation causes undue hardship to the employer.

Besides these regulations, the Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA) prohibits employers from firing workers with the explanation that they are old if the worker is over forty years of age. The reason why this law applies to the protection of older employees at termination is plausible because age discrimination is prevalent in workplaces.

Thus, employers need to make sure that their termination decisions are considered by these federal laws in order to avoid legal issues. However, a failure to honor these protections even in an at-will setting leads to legal suits, liability claims, and severe brand image tarnishing. Research conducted by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission showed that over 67,000 discrimination cases were filed in the year 2020 alone; it, therefore, pays to follow these federal directives on discharge of employees.

Understanding and complying with federal laws against employment discrimination is essential for both employers and employees in maintaining a fair and legally compliant workplace.

Exceptions to at-will employment by state

Even though at-will employment is the majority rule in most states, there are recognized main exceptions to at-will employment by state that offer employee protection. These exceptions may help to limit the dismissal of employees and bosses at their discretion in what may otherwise be at will circumstances.

Public policy exceptions: Generally, employees cannot be dismissed for reasons amounting to a violation of the public policy. For example, whenever an employee fails in being forced to engage in unlawful practices or conducts reporting unlawful practices (whistle-blowing), he/she is protected by public policy exceptions. For instance, California and New Jersey can be referred as states with policy exceptions that highly protect employees against unfair dismissals concerning these matters.

Implied contract exceptions: Sometimes, state laws even allow employers and employees to have an implied contract even when the employment is not written. These contracts may be in the form of verbal or other formal contracts such as work manuals or acts that indicate there is a continued employment contract. Some states like New York and Texas approve implied contracts as grounds for wrongful dismissal in which employees have the right to sue the employer for unfair discharge if there was an expectation of continued employment.

Covenant of good faith and fair dealing: Presently, the states of Massachusetts and Montana have adopted the covenant of good faith and fair dealing. This means that employers have to obey the principles of good faith when dismissing an employee. Failure to do so can lead to good faith termination lawsuits, where employees sue for wrongful termination based on claims of bad faith or unfair treatment. If an employee believes he or she was discharged unfairly or illogically, they can sue for wrongful termination part-bona fide termination action. This protection means that employers cannot fire employees to avoid having to pay them things such as commissions or retirement packages.

Such exceptions to at-will employment by state make legal provisions that mediate the relationship between employers and their employees. At-will employees should understand the protections of their state to be informed of their rights when being employed at-will.

How to navigate implied contracts in employment?

The purely presumed relations may exist in at-will employment where promises, employer’s handbook, or employer and employee’s actions give the employee a reason to expect that he or she cannot be dismissed without a cause. These are usually unwritten as the name suggests but can make employees to think that they have a long-term employment contract with the firm.

Here is how you can navigate your implied contracts in employment:

• Employment policies that designate clear disciplinary measures before dismissal or dismissal policies that are contained in the employee manuals.
• Promises by supervisors which indicate to the employees that they will remain employed in the company.
• During interviews, or any announcement or practice suggesting that employees will not be dismissed for any other reason than unsatisfactory performance or misbehavior.

Thus, for the employees it is important to realise how they can work with implied contracts. If they think they are unjustly fired for breach of an implied contract, they should consider the written and verbal promises, mail correspondence, written company handbooks they signed or performance review that may help make their stand.

Employers, therefore, should not encourage themselves to give empty promises of job security, if they are unwilling to keep the promises. Policies in handbooks that are clearly written, along with regular communication should go a long way to prevent the formation of implied contracts in the organization.

If an implied contract is in question, employees and their employers should consult legal representation in order to better understand the legal nuances of the contract and one’s role.

Understanding the Balance in At-Will Employment

While at-will employment offers flexibility for both employers and employees, it is important to recognize the legal processes in place. Federal and state exceptions, such as anti-discrimination laws and implied contract protections, ensure fair treatment and prevent potential misuse of termination rights. This knowledge is essential for creating a balanced and compliant workplace, where both employers and employees can exercise their rights responsibly.

Final Thoughts

It is possible to conclude that at-will employment has its advantages and disadvantages for the employers and employees. Although it opens the possibility for termination without a valid reason, it includes regard for the legal safeguards, including non-discrimination and federal/state laws.

To avoid accidentally breaking the law and to document many processes to decrease the chances of a lawsuit, it is useful to use various technologies. On the other hand, the employee should know his rights as well as when he will be shielded from wrongful termination by an implied contract or any of the state exceptions. Employers and employees should go to work with at-will employment with an understanding of the pros and cons.

FAQS:

1. What is at-will employment?

At-will employment is a type of employment contract where either the employer or the employee can terminate the relationship at any time, without needing to provide a reason, as long as the termination is lawful.

2. What are the federal exceptions to at-will employment?

Other federal statutes, including the Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, the ADA, and the ADEA expressly forbid discharge based on discrimination arising from race, gender, age, disability or other forms of discrimination. The at-will employment doctrine also has exceptions along the following laws.

3. What are the state exceptions to at-will employment?

Many states have exceptions to at-will employment, including:

• Public policy exceptions: Employers cannot dismiss employees for conduct that is unlawful under the laws of the particular state (for instance, the employee’s decision to refrain from contributing to an unlawful activity).
• Implied contract exceptions: Several states consider implied contracts and they may arise through oral promises or through handbooks or recognized policies.
• Covenant of good faith and fair dealing: It is accepted that some states require that terminations must be done bona fide thereby preventing employers from act in of mala fide.

4. What are the rights of an at-will employee?

The at-will employees can quit their positions without prior notice and without any reason at all. Employees are also shielded from unfair dismissal, including those that are done based on discrimination and or revenge, by federal and state laws.

5. What challenges come with at-will employment?

The main problems of at-will employment for the employees are the absence of employment protection and the possibility of discharge without explanation. Employers may face legal problems from the at-will employment if the termination is not conducted well, particularly in areas such as discrimination or the implied contract.

6. How can contract modifications nullify at-will employment?

If the employer and employee are clear on certain aspects of the employment contract concerning job security or termination policies, it can change or erase the ‘at-will employment’ status of the company. Promises made in written in the form of agreement, or handbooks, or oral statements that employment will be ‘Guaranteed, ‘Sure,’ or ‘Certain’ give rise to an implied contract that negates at-will employment.

7. How does at-will employment compare to other types?

Different from contractual or union employment relationships that have clear provisions about dismissals, at-will employment provides parties greater freedom of action. However, it does not offer the degree of job security and all the legal processes that come with most other forms of employment.

8. What rights do at-will employees have?

In the case of at-will employment, workers can be dismissed without any reason, but they cannot be persecuted under federal and state laws against discrimination and wrongful dismissal. They also have a dominant right to quit his or her job at any one time without any reason or by having to give any notice period.

Article Author – Gino Peters

Gino Peters is the Commercial Director at ThisWorks, with a rich history of nearly a decade in international payroll. Throughout his tenure, he has consistently kept abreast of evolving labor legislation, ensuring that ThisWorks remains at the forefront of industry knowledge. Beyond his vast expertise, Gino is deeply committed to advising and guiding clients and partners with precise insights. His leadership guarantees that all content and operations at ThisWorks meet the highest standards of clarity, accuracy, and compliance.
Follow him on Linkedin

Book a free consultation with Gino Peters